You Said “I’m In.” Your Team Heard “I’m Not.”

You Said “I’m In.” Your Team Heard “I’m Not.”

November 20, 2026•3 min read

Slide Nine

You’ve rehearsed this deck four times, and you still don’t believe slide nine.

Last week the CEO laid out the new plan: merge two regional offices and move every client to one account team. You had concerns, real ones. But the room was nodding, the CEO was smiling, and you heard yourself say, “I’m in.”

Now you’re the one in front of your team, clicking to slide nine. Your voice sounds fine. Your stomach doesn’t.

Your sharpest manager raises her hand. “How does this work for our biggest accounts?”

You give the answer you were given. She nods politely. You both know it wasn’t an answer.

When Nobody Says "Wait"

Even the biggest boardrooms get this wrong. This month in Fortune, Yale’s Jeffrey Sonnenfeld argued that Nvidia’s directors had become too deferential to question their celebrated CEO before a governance crisis hit. He made the same point in Harvard Business Review back in 2002: great boards build a culture where people openly push back. A boardroom and a Tuesday staff meeting fail the same way. Nobody says “wait.”

The Meeting After the Meeting

Here’s what happens next. Your team senses you don’t believe the plan, so they don’t either. The real conversation moves to the parking lot. Someone says, “This’ll never work,” and instead of shutting it down, you shrug and mutter, “Not my call.”

That’s the worst of both worlds. You didn’t speak up when it counted, and now you’re quietly undercutting the plan after it was decided.

Being a yes person is also exhausting. Defending something you don’t believe drains more energy than any hard conversation ever will.

Confession time: early in my career I was a professional nodder. I agreed so often I should have expensed my chiropractor. It didn’t make me a team player. It made me a bobblehead with a business card.

The Coach's Take: Weigh In, Then Buy In

Patrick Lencioni puts it plainly in The Advantage: “If people don’t weigh in, they can’t buy in.”

Some decisions are yours alone. Plenty belong to “us.” When it’s an “us” decision and you skip the debate, you don’t get unity. You get polite silence, then the parking lot. That’s catabolic energy, and it spreads.

Speaking up isn’t disloyal. Loyalty means putting your honest concerns on the table, in the room, with the people who can act on them. Integrity means that once the decision is made, your word holds, even if you argued the other side. Healthy Conflict and honest Communication are what earn real Commitment.

Your Playbook for This Week

  1. Check your own belief first. Before you present any plan, ask yourself whether you actually believe it. If you don’t, your next conversation is with your boss, not your team.

  2. Put your dissent on the table. Say it in the room, plainly and respectfully: “Here’s my concern, and here’s why.” One honest sentence beats a month of hallway grumbling.

  3. Invite people to poke holes. When you bring a plan to your team, ask, “Where’s the hole in this? What would you change?” People invest in what they help shape.

  4. Vote, decide, then 86 the bad talk. Back in my restaurant days, “86” meant it was off the menu. Once the decision is made, trashing the ideas that lost is off the menu too. Jeff Bezos calls this disagree and commit, and he says that as the boss, he does it too.

A Better Slide Nine

Rewind to the executive meeting. This time, when the nodding starts, you say, “I have a concern about our biggest accounts.” The CEO asks you to say more, and the plan gets better. When you present slide nine, you believe it, and you ask your team to poke holes in it. Your sharpest manager raises her hand again. This time, her idea goes on the whiteboard.

So what plan are you nodding along to that you don’t actually believe?

If you want to learn how to use your voice to express concerns while still being a great leader, head over and grab your complimentary Core Energy Coaching Session HERE.

And remember,
When focus, purpose, and action align, success follows.

Leadership clarityintentional leadershipleadership communicationteam growthleadership empowermentleadership developmentLeadership under pressure
Matthew Hoffman
Back to Blog

Stay Connected With Us

Sign Up For Our Weekly Blog And Impactful Videos